The Low Anthem formed in Providence, Rhode Island, around 2006 and released Oh My God, Charlie Darwin in 2009 on Nonesuch Records after initial self-release. The album became one of the more critically acclaimed folk records of its year, praised for its atmospheric slowness, its unusual instrumentation (amplified saw, instruments found or repurposed from old objects), and its willingness to sit in silence and space rather than fill every moment with motion.
The band occupied the opposite end of the folk revival's spectrum from the anthemic energy of Mumford and Sons or the communal sing-along of the Lumineers. Their folk was austere, deliberate, and occasionally unsettling: music for careful listeners rather than festival crowds.
The Album's Character
Oh My God, Charlie Darwin was produced and recorded with unusual care for its texture. The band had developed a performance practice of recording in locations with specific acoustic properties (churches, empty theaters, outdoor spaces) and using unconventional instruments alongside conventional ones.
The results were recordings with a specific presence: something felt genuinely old, genuinely found rather than manufactured, in the sounds. The title track's combination of sparse acoustic picking, distant harmonics, and Ben Knox Miller's plaintive vocals created an atmosphere that was difficult to locate in time. It could have been 1910 or 2009; the music occupied its own temporal space.
According to critical coverage in Pitchfork, Uncut, and various folk-specific publications, the album was recognized as one of the more distinctive and serious folk albums of its year, though its atmosphere and slow pace made it less immediately accessible than more anthemic folk-pop releases.
Providence and New England Folk
New England had its own folk tradition that was somewhat distinct from the Appalachian and Southern American traditions that dominated the mainstream Americana narrative. The region's history of shape-note singing, its connections to various European folk traditions through immigration, and its specific landscape and cultural texture gave New England folk music a character that was different from Southern or Midwestern folk.
The Low Anthem's Providence roots were audible in their music, though not in any cliched sense. The specific quality of their slowness, their interest in the past as present rather than the past as nostalgia, and their particular sonic palette had the character of a specific place and tradition.
Instrumentation and Approach
The band's use of unusual instruments was part of a deliberate aesthetic program. The musical saw, amplified through a contact microphone, provided an eerie singing tone that was ancient-sounding without being archaic. Various other non-standard instruments and found sounds were incorporated into recordings in ways that served the music's specific emotional goals.
This approach was connected to the broader folk revival's interest in traditional and pre-commercial instrument traditions, but the Low Anthem's use of unusual instruments was more musically sophisticated than mere folk authenticity signaling. Each choice served a specific sonic purpose.
What They Represented
The Low Anthem represented one of the more serious and demanding strands of the 2009-2012 folk revival: music that required patient attention rather than offering immediate gratification. Their presence on major festival lineups (Newport Folk, Bonnaroo) alongside more anthemic folk-pop acts demonstrated the revival's range.
For younger artists developing their own approaches to folk music during this period, the Low Anthem offered a model of aesthetic seriousness that was distinct from both the commercial folk-pop mainstream and the more explicitly traditional old-time revival. Their work suggested that contemporary folk music could aspire to a different kind of beauty than was available through those routes.
---
FAQ
When did The Low Anthem release Oh My God, Charlie Darwin? The album was initially self-released before Nonesuch Records picked it up for wider distribution in April 2009.
What made the Low Anthem's sonic approach distinctive? Use of unusual instruments (amplified saw, found objects), recording in spaces with specific acoustic properties, and a deliberate slowness and atmospheric quality that was unusual in the anthemic folk-pop revival context.
Where is The Low Anthem from? Providence, Rhode Island, giving their folk music a specific New England character distinct from the Southern and Midwestern Americana traditions that dominated mainstream narrative.
Were they commercially successful in the folk revival? They received strong critical recognition and played significant festival dates, but their atmospheric, demanding aesthetic made them a critics' favorite rather than a mainstream commercial act within the revival.
What did the Low Anthem represent in the broader folk revival? The serious, demanding, atmospherically inclined end of the revival: music for careful listeners that required patience and attention rather than offering immediate anthemic gratification.
More from the Americana desk
Honest, working reporting on the business of independent music from From The Stem.
Visit the Americana vertical →